I’m on a diet.
I know I’m not supposed to use that word, “diet”….I’m supposed to call it a “lifestyle” or “program”, but you can tell that to my belly when it’s growling at me tonight before bedtime. I swear it’s saying, “grrrrr damned diet grrrrr”.
I’ve been on diets my whole life. I remember the first time my weight was brought to my attention. I can recall the exact moment as though it was yesterday. Where I was, who I was with….and who let the cat out of the bag.
It was John B…..I’ll just say “B” because there are people from my home town who read this blog, (I have come to realize from emails responding to past blogs) and even though they will undoubtedly figure it out, I’ll spare him for the time being.
I was attending Reverend George A. Brown Memorial School, and I was in the 5th grade. It was Sister Grace Angela’s homeroom, 7:45am, and I was wearing my navy and gray pleated (all the way around…front to back) uniform jumper skirt. You had to wear the one-piece jumper until 7th and 8th grade, and then you could wear the separate pleated all the way around skirt, with a white button down and Navy sweater. Then, if you were lucky, you could beg your way into the public high school, if not, it was off to Pope John with you for more of the same.
The aforementioned pleated all the way around skirt is important to the story because of the very construction of said skirt. See, any woman who wears skirts will tell you that pleats of any kind are a fashion challenge no matter who wears them. But when you start putting tiny pleats across the front, around the hips, and over the derriere…well, it could make even Kate Moss look girthy.
And when you’re a girl from Italian heritage, and perhaps even slightly over indulged at the dinner table by your relatives, because when compared to the rest of your family, you’re considered skinny, and you’re forced to put on a skirt with 117 pleats, there’s risk involved. Or in my case, it may look like you stepped into the center of a gingham plaid golf umbrella.
So, there I was, in my standard-issue Catholic school uniform (the before picture) standing next to Katie Johnson (the after) and John B made a comment about my enormous butt.
What’s interesting about this story, (to me at least, you may have fallen asleep on your keyboard by now) is that I don’t actually remember the comment verbatim. What I DO remember is the sudden awareness that I was different for the very first time. Up until that moment…the second he made that comment, I had no clue that I was big, small, or unusual in any way. I was shocked at the announcement. Not to mention that I LOVED him…he was my big secret crush. I thought I was perfect until I was told otherwise. And I was never the same after that.
It pretty much breaks down like this: Before John B….and after John B.
I knew from that day forward that I was overweight….even when I wasn’t.
I’ve often wondered if he’d never said that, if no one had (because unfortunately over the years, he wouldn’t be the last.) would I have ever known? And how would my life be different without that knowledge about myself?
Would it have just been something I would have outgrown? Or would it still have been this stigma and constant opponent I find myself up against?
Interesting question.
He became my friend in the following years, and I think if he knew now that he had such an impact on me, he’d die a thousand deaths. We were just kids.
But I’ll never forget it.
Especially while I total my points.



{ 7 comments }
Well, I think you are perfect. Is this a little too little and a little too late?
I have a daughter who looks a lot like a 14 year old version of you (but she spends hours straightening her curly blond hair).
And I am raising this daughter by myself without the benefit of growing up with sisters.
So, on an intellectual level I understand, but as a guy and heavyset at that, I just can’t get there. I wish I could, I want my daughter to get past this crap.
On Thursday it is a stupid world we live in.
If my daughter did not resemble you, I swould be building images of you and that Catholic girl uniform………
Oooohhhh, yeah, I can VERY much relate to your story, Cass! I, as an Italian-american girl growing up in NJ, was called “toothpick” and other things by my grandparents…but for the School of American Ballet, I was told, at age 12, that I was VERY overweight for a dancer. Thus began the endless stream of diets and body-image issues that continue to this day.
I’ve never considered you at all overweight (and my husband, upon viewing “Ask Cassidy” for the first time, dubbed you a PERFECT GODDESS), but I know about the entertainment industry, and how success sometimes equals how thin you are. So I get it, more than you know!
Anyway, I’m counting my points, too, as of Jan 7th) and empathize with the growling tummy in the evening. Want a points buddy? Heeee.
Love ya,
Torch
I can totally empathize with you.
I was never a stick figure, but I used to be really in shape (from running) and now I have ballooned into someone I don’t recognize.
Death, love, loss of love, loneliness have all taken their toll…
So as I sit here counting my points, I try to place my weight gain one incident, but can not, it’s just been a very viscous cycle.
You’re gorgeous, and I just wanted to tell you that.
I just wrote a long post about body image, weight, and being a girl who has dealt with it her entire life. Have you ever read “Appetites” by Caroline Knapp or “Perfect Girls, starving daughters” by Courtney Martin?
Both amazing books on the culture that we live in and how tragic it can be for us.
I had that moment too! I dated a guy who was my absolute best friend. I could talk to him about anything. But he would always be loose with comments about how I looked. And all they did was make me want to eat and I did nothing but gain weight while I was with him, which made the situation worse and worse. And I couldn’t understand how someone I considered my best friend could make me feel so awful at the same time.
I was never super skinny by any means, but man, I will kill to be the weight now, that I was when I first start dating him.
I always think back to him when I try to figure out when I got so insecure. I use to be so confident. And it has taken me a long time to bounce back and not let that relationship dictate how I should feel about myself. Trying to make 2008 the year I become whole again! MEN! LOL
Cassidy – you are absolutely beautiful and sexy plus or minus five, ten pounds or whatever. Who cares! We just saw the show tonight at the Bitter End and you looked fantastic as always – and you and the band sounded as great as ever.
Diet, no diet, whatever… just keep singing and performing and knowing that you are beautiful and confident. Don’t waste too much energy thinking about that other stuff; it’s all a big conspiracy by the beauty and diet industries to keep us women spending money on their crap, anyway
Keep singing and writing… love ya!
(PS: LOVED the Pearl Jam and Bob Dylan tonight; just incredible.)
Late on checking in on this too but I still need to comment.
OK – if you and John B are both at the 20th – he better give you a hug and an apology. And I’m sure he will. We first met a few years following and you were always a hottie and you are a beautiful woman with a beautiful heart most importantly Cass, so don’t ever forget that.
Comments on this entry are closed.